Reality is socially constructed berger and luckmann, 1966 and so is constantly changing. However, the positivism paradigm has been criticised for its exclusion of the discovery dimensions in inquiry and the underdetermination of theory deshpande, 1983. However, the positivism paradigm has been criticised for its exclusion of the discovery dimensions in inquiry and the underdetermination of. In this book chapter, guba and lincoln analyze four research paradigms. Ejm research design and data analysis in realism research. The maturing of social science over the past fifty years has not been accompanied by a concomitant matur. Pdf competing paradigms in qualitative research semantic. In fourth generation evaluation, guba and lincoln present a strong, unequivocal argument for the epistemological, methodological, and ethical superiority of their refined constructivist inquiry paradigm for the political and practical demands of program evaluation. She is author, coauthor, or editor of such books as naturalistic inquiry and fourth generation evaluation both with egon g. Guba 1978, 1981, guba and lincoln 1981, lincoln and guba 1981, and lincoln 1981 have made the case that all four. A paradigm shift is under way in many fields, they contend, and go on to describe the different assumptions of the two approaches regarding. Theory of connectivity as an emergent solution to innovative learning strategies. The primary mode of the research inquiry of positivism is theorytesting based on deduction layder 1993.
It is related to ontology, the study of being crotty, 1998. I i handbook of ualitative research timothy davidson. Epistemology is concerned with providing a philosophical grounding for deciding what kinds of knowledge are possible and how we ensure it is adequate and legitimate maynard, 1994. To answer to the question, healy and perry 2000 assert that the quality of a study in each paradigm should be judged by its own paradigms terms. Ontologically speaking, there are multiple realities or multiple truths based on ones construction of reality. Rather than opting for the criteria promoted by one variety, paradigm, moment, or school within qualitative research, practicing. Guba and lincoln 1998 stated that a research paradigm is intrinsically associated with the concepts of ontology.
Fourth generation evaluation sage publications inc. Qualitative and quantitative research paradigms in. Vice president of division j postsecondary education of the american educational research association, dr. Lincoln t he global community of qualitative researchers is midway between two extremes, searching for a new middle, moving in several different directions at the same time. Introduction the discipline and practice of qualitative research norman k. From time to time, articles are published in ep that evoke comments from readers. In this chapter we analyze four paradigms that currently are competing. An ontology that encompasses positivist and constructivist approaches to the social sciences. A philosophical reflection stephen kwadwo antwi 1 kasim hamza 2. For a positivist, reality is out there in the world independent of the researcher pring, 2000a, p. Pdf paradigmatic controversies, contradictions, and. Pdf competing paradigms in qualitative research n carvalho. Qualitative and quantitative research paradigms in business research. Inquiry into issues of trustworthiness and quality in narrative studies.
Lincoln in this chapter we analyze four paradigms that currently are competing, or have until recently. Sociologists and psychologists have used the method since the 1940s e. Lincoln and guba describe a series of techniques that can be used to conduct qualitative research that achieves the criteria they outline. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools.
However, such a criterion does not fully nor explicitly address the issue of quality or rigour. Sorting through research paradigms athabasca university. Showing how science is limited by its dominant mode of investigation, lincoln and guba propose an alternative paradigm a naturalistic rather than rationalistic method of inquiry in which the investigator avoids manipulating research outcomes. Start studying reading guba and lincoln 1994 competing paradigms in qualitative research. Lyman traditions, preferences, and postures in applied qualitative research. Guba despite the widespread proliferation of professional ethical standards such as those of the american psychological association ad hoc 1973, 1982, ethical concerns continue to plague social research. In this chapter we analyze four paradigms that currently are competing, or have until recently com peted, for acceptance as the paradigm of choice in. Jennifer greene, cornell university i would warmly recommend it as stimulating and challenging reading.
A variety of conceptions of qualitative research exist, with competing claims as to what counts as good quality work. Guba and lincoln point to the inherent problems faced by previous generations of evaluatorspolitics, ethical dilemmas, imperfections and gaps, inconclusive deductions and lay the blame for failure and nonutilization at the feet of the unquestioned reliance on the scientificpositivist. A perspective abstract many narrative studies subscribe to the criterion of verisimilitude as a form of quality check. Inquiry into issues of trustworthiness and quality in. We are pleased to accept your invitation, open epub for. A paradigm shift is under way in many fields, they contend, and go on to describe the. Guba and lincoln point to the inherent problems faced by previous generations of evaluatorspolitics, ethical dilemmas, imperfections and gaps, inconclusive deductions and lay the blame for failure and nonutilization at the feet of the unquestioned reliance on. Validity, reliability and triangulation in case study.
Lincoln 1994, the inquirer is cast in the role of instigator and facilitator p. Pdf competing paradigms in qualitative research guba. Quality and trustworthiness in qualitative research in. A paradigm is a basic belief system or a worldview that guides the researcher. Rather than opting for the criteria promoted by one variety, paradigm, moment, or school within qualitative research, practicing researchers can learn valuable lessons from each one. Lincoln and gubas evaluative criteria qualitative research. Reality emerges when consciousness engages with objects which are already pregnant with meaning crotty, 1998, p. For example, while the terms reliability and validity are essential criterion for quality in quantitative paradigms, in. Articulating rationale of the research defends why specific choices and decisions had been made in the process and, at the same time, it. Fourth generation evaluation represents a monumental shift in evaluation practice. Contributions should be to the point, concise, and easy for readers to tra. It has been argued that positivist and constructivist ontologies are irreconcilable. Competing paradigms in qualitative research egon g.
Pdf an introduction to research paradigms researchgate. Guba and lincoln 1994 affirm that both qualitative and quantitative methods may be used appropriately with any research paradigm, but the questions of methods are secondary to questions of paradigm. Naturalistic inquiry is a qualitative research method used to examine peoples life experiences in contextbound settings lincoln and guba, 1985 in this case, breast cancer patients and. Seale qualitative research quality in qualitative research. This is the interpretive approach, which aims to explain the subjective reasons.
According to lincoln and guba 2000, positivisms naive realism holds that reality is both real and. Lincoln 1994, the inquirer is cast in the role of instigator and facili tator p. The work of lincoln and guba reflects these more recent shifts. Entering the field of qualitative research norman k. Patton 2002 referred to these criteria as traditional scientific research criteria p. The postmodern paradigms that we discussed postmodernist critical theory and constructivism 1 were in contention with the received positivist and postpositivist paradigms. According to lincoln and guba 2000, positivisms naive realism holds that reality is both real and apprehendable. Competing paradigms in qualitative research egan g. Exploring the philosophical underpinnings of research. In this discussion, i focus on four worldviews that inform qualitative. Lincoln and guba 1985 argue that establishing the trustworthiness of a research report lies at the heart of issues conventionally discussed as validity and reliabilitysothatfourquestionshave,fromwithinthemodernistparadigm,been.
627 80 679 473 483 588 294 1461 1221 313 19 845 149 1399 1522 96 346 88 451 1541 769 982 1363 738 901 219 685 32 92 907